hexandboost

home / articles / knock on a turbo r18

Build series · Engine intelligence

Knock on a turbo R18: what the logs actually show

Ask anyone where a turbo engine knocks and they will say at full boost, high in the revs. I assumed the same. Then I counted.

Where it really happens

On 16 October 2026 my logs recorded 35 moments where the engine's knock control stepped in. Thirty-two of them were at light throttle, between about 1,200 and 2,750 rpm, with the manifold at or below atmospheric pressure.

On 7 November, on better fuel, it was 12 of 15.

One small region, 2,000 to 2,500 rpm on light throttle, showed knock on 18 of 42 drives.

Knock under boost does exist on this engine. It clusters between 5,100 and 5,800 rpm. But it is the rare case. Most of the knock on my turbo R18 happens while pulling away gently in traffic.

Why part-throttle knock costs full-throttle power

Honda's knock control keeps a single running number for the whole engine. Knock pushes it up quickly. It comes back down slowly.

So when the engine knocks lightly at 2,000 rpm and I put my foot down ten seconds later, that number is still raised, and it is still taking timing away. On this car each tenth of that number costs about 1.2 degrees under boost. Arriving at a pull with it at 1.1 or 1.2, compared with a clean 0.85, costs 3 to 4 degrees of timing at full boost before the pull has even begun.

The spark at full boost was being set by what happened in traffic.

Other Honda tuners have seen the same band. The fix is the unglamorous one: take timing out at part throttle until the knock stops. My self-learning ignition reached that conclusion by itself, since nearly all of its first corrections were in exactly this range.

How this car compares with other turbo R18s

I compared my calibration with everything I could find published on turbo R18 builds and on similar engines.

  • Ignition timing under boost: conservative. At full boost my engine sees 3 to 6 degrees of advance. Others report around 12 on this engine, and 8 to 15 is normal for the type. I am 5 to 10 degrees behind them, and about 2 degrees under the point where my own engine starts to knock.
  • Mixture: rich. I command richer than most. On the first 13.5 psi drive the engine actually ran richer still, which costs power and is not a target.
  • Boost: aggressive. 13.5 psi is above the 6 to 12 psi most turbo R18s run.
  • Knock control: kept. Most turbo conversions on this engine turn Honda's knock control down or off. I left its limits alone and made it more sensitive under boost.

The common recipe is modest boost, normal timing and the knock control defeated. Mine is high boost, low timing and everything watching. Both get to a similar place. Mine is safer if the engine does knock, and harder on the fuel system and the connecting rods.

When knock does appear under boost

The ignition is retarded, as Honda designed. On top of that I reduce the boost target in step with the retard. On one logged drive the knock control was holding 6 degrees of retard on boost on average and 13.5 at worst. An engine in that state should not also be asked for full boost.

One cylinder was different

Knock on this engine is not shared evenly. In an idle test on 2 November, one cylinder produced 34 of 57 knock counts and was clearly the weakest of the four. Under load it accounted for roughly four in ten of the real knock events.

Setting the valve clearances did not cure it. That cylinder turned out to be running lean at small injector openings: 3 % more fuel gave it 30 % more torque at idle. It now has its own fuel trim. The before and after are in balancing the four cylinders.

What I still do not know

  • Why this engine tolerates so little timing under boost. The evidence points to exhaust back-pressure from the turbine around 5,500 rpm more than to fuel quality. I have not measured it.
  • Exhaust temperature. There is no sensor fitted.
  • Torque. There is no dyno figure, so I cannot say what the last 3.5 psi is really worth. Once an engine is knock limited, more boost can add heat without adding power.
  • Per-cylinder knock under boost has not been logged live.

The logs changed what I thought the problem was. I went looking for knock at the top of the rev range and found most of it at the bottom. I would not have known that without counting.

By Haris, Hex and Boost.

Have a car the usual tools cannot touch?

Tell me the car, the engine, the gearbox and what you want it to do. I reply to every serious enquiry.