home / articles / drive by pedal vs drive by torque
Build series ยท Boost and torque
Drive by pedal vs drive by torque
In a stock Civic Rebirth, your right foot commands a throttle angle. In mine, it makes a request. The computer decides how much air, and therefore how much boost, that request deserves in this gear at this engine speed. That one change in thinking is what makes a turbo car on a factory ECU drivable.
How the factory car does it
The Rebirth has an electronic throttle. The pedal is not connected to the engine by a cable. It goes through a pedal map, which gives a demand, and a motor moves the throttle to match.
That map is far from linear. When I measured it, 31 % pedal already gave 47 % demand, and 44 % pedal gave 74 %. Above 30 km/h nearly all of the engine's response arrives in a narrow band of pedal travel. Honda does this so a modest engine feels eager.
Put a turbo on that and the eagerness becomes a problem. A third of the pedal opens the throttle most of the way, the turbo wakes up, and you have full boost when you only asked for a little.
The idea
My brief to myself was one line: the pedal is a torque request, and boost is how it is met.
So the pedal no longer decides the throttle angle on its own. The ECU works out the most charge the engine should have right now, from the gear, the engine speed and the drive mode, and then delivers the share of it the pedal is asking for.
One rule made it safe to develop on the road: my code can only ever take away from what the pedal asked for. It can never make the car do more than the driver did.
Stage one: the throttle as a boost limiter
When I started, the car had a spring wastegate with no control. The only thing I could command was the throttle. So the first version, live on 1 October 2026, held a boost cap for each gear and closed the throttle just enough to stay under it. With my foot flat, the throttle sat well under half open and the boost stayed on its cap.
It was not smooth at first. The first build made the throttle hunt, and boost rippled with it. After each gearshift the pressure spiked past the cap and took up to two seconds to come back. After a revision it settled in under half a second. I wrote those first two logs up separately.
By 4 October the boost was proportional to the pedal: nothing below about 40 % of pedal travel, then a straight line up to the cap.
Why the throttle alone is the wrong tool
Holding boost down with the throttle works, and it wastes energy. The turbo keeps compressing air against a half-closed throttle. That costs heat and exhaust back-pressure, and the turbo is working hard for boost you are throwing away.
The right tool is the wastegate. If the turbine is given less exhaust, it makes less boost in the first place.
Stage two: three layers
Once my electronic wastegate was on the car, the job split into three layers:
- Demand. The pedal asks for a share of the charge the turbo can actually deliver in this gear at this engine speed.
- Supply. The wastegate holds the pressure in the pipe just above what is being asked for.
- Metering. The throttle sits nearly wide open and does the fine trimming. It remains the final cap if the wastegate cannot hold the pressure down.
I wanted the logic to be indifferent to the hardware. In my notes: the model wants a certain air charge, and it gets it through whatever gate position that takes. Change the turbo and the request stays the same.
Two controllers, one pressure
The first night with both systems live taught me something. The wastegate overshot by a few kPa. The throttle saw too much pressure and closed. Closing the throttle raised the pressure in the pipe further. The wastegate's safety limit then opened the gate completely and the pull collapsed.
Two controllers were fighting over the same number. The fix was to give each one a single job: the wastegate sets the boost, and when boost is on target the throttle is told to stay out of the way.
Knowing what the turbo can do
There is no point asking for boost the turbo cannot make at 2,500 rpm. I measured what this turbo delivers with the gate shut, in every gear across the rev range, from 4,851 logged samples. The request can never exceed that. It keeps the control from winding itself up chasing a target that is physically out of reach.
What it feels like to drive
- Off boost it is a normal Civic. Below about 20 % pedal, or below roughly 2,300 rpm, the gate is parked open and the car drives like a standard 1.8.
- The pedal is progressive. In third gear at 3,600 rpm, a quarter pedal asks for about atmospheric pressure, half pedal for about 4 psi, and so on up.
- Each gear has its own limit. The lower gears are held back, where the tyres and the gearbox would suffer most.
- The mode changes the request. The factory ECON button selects a softer line with lower boost.
The numbers
- 16 October 2026: second gear at full throttle holds 153 to 155 kPa against a target of 153, from 5,400 to 6,200 rpm. Part throttle tracks within 8 kPa.
- 17 October: 170 to 175 kPa against a 167 target at 10 psi.
- 7 November, first drive at 13.5 psi: not clean. It peaked at 14.5 psi, 11 kPa over target on one gearshift, and overshot by almost 26 kPa at one point in second gear.
- 9 November: third gear holds 184 to 190 kPa against 186 to 189.
What is not right yet
After a boosted third-to-fourth shift the car falls flat for a moment: the throttle closes to about half while my foot is still down, and the gearshift "hole" is roughly three times deeper than it was before boost. I know the mechanism and have candidate fixes built. They are not on the car yet.
On one drive up the Kalar Kahar climb the system dumped boost five times when I merely eased off the pedal. That one is fixed.
Why it matters
Most turbo conversions bolt on power and leave the pedal behaving as it did. The result is a car that is either off boost or fully on it. Making the factory ECU reason in torque is what lets a turbo Rebirth be driven smoothly in traffic and still use all of its boost when asked. The safety side of the same logic is in how the car makes boost safely.
By Haris, Hex and Boost.
Have a car the usual tools cannot touch?
Tell me the car, the engine, the gearbox and what you want it to do. I reply to every serious enquiry.